Showing posts with label Merge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Merge. Show all posts

Friday, August 15, 2008

Three Models of Leardship for the Geekiest Muppets of our time: Or why Yahoo did not merge with Microsoft in the First Place




Introduction

I was a Director of the Order Fulfillment Applications in Information Technology [IT] Department of “EL ARADO”. At the time, my company was in the verge to be merged with a competitor, i.e. Plow of the Sea Inc. Facing this merged, I had the feeling that in order to lead this merge, first I needed to know how to follow. Furthermore, I followed the suggestions provided by the Vice-president [VP], whom by the way, I also considered my mentor. Therefore, I conducted a research aiming to gather information about three different leadership models that we could utilize to take appropriate decisions and implement a plan of action, to meet on one hand, the expectations of the new management; and on the other, to prepare myself to effectively facilitate and support my staff throughout the merging process. Well, I need to tell you that I was overwhelmed by the tremendous amount of theories, models, styles, approaches and taxonomies on this relevant developing discipline, as it is denominated by Gary Yukl (2002) in his book “Leadership In Organizations” (p. 6). [Nevertheless, I was also very motivated because I knew that after my research eventually would have put me in the position by which I would have had been much better equipped to, handle the unexpected, manage the expected and assist my staff and the new management to face those then new ‘merging’ challenges effectively.]


Major Leadership approaches


According to Yukl (2002) there are three major characteristics that researchers use as a way for understanding leadership effectiveness, i.e. characteristics of the leader, of the followers and finally, of the situation. As a result, theory and research has been classified, as Yukl explains, in five major perspectives or approaches: [1] Trait, [2] behavior, [3] power-influence, [4] situational and [5] integrative. (p. 9 -11) I conceptualized these approaches as dimensions that overlap and interlock within different ‘degrees and shades’ in any given instantiation of leadership. It seems that from these mere general perspectives, practitioners can create useful frameworks to improve or apply effective leadership skills at different levels for their organizations. It is within this context that I understand frameworks as continuums that integrate in their underneath different approaches, which in turn have different theories using dissimilar taxonomies and in their “surface or interface’ interpretative descriptions and/or prescriptions to plan, decide and act effectively. I think that the figure 1 below is a good example of how one might view the entire field of leadership; I could also view it as a sample of an integrative approach of leadership. In reality, the figure 1 is the exhibit of the Army leadership framework that I extracted from the Field Manual No 22 -100 titled “Army Leadership Be, Know and Do.”



Figure 1



As you see the base of this truncated pyramid is labeled values and attributes, I think this belongs to the trait approach; this perspective is the oldest and has been around since 1930’s. The next level is labeled “Direct Leadership”, I think that this approach is centered on how things are done and so falls in the realm of the behavior approach. The immediate superior level is coined “Organizational leadership”. Some of the actions within this area are geared to convince, motivate, or influence people to achieve those imperative tasks in a proper and timely way; and thus it seems to be based on the power-influence approach. “Lastly, the last and highest level is called “Strategic Leadership”. This is were the leaders experience or “suffer” [it all depends, I guess, on how one looks at it] a great deal of uncertainty, these is the core of every action and from this vantage point leaders are the ones who must set the path and for such they need to spell and outlined for the entire organization their vision. CEOs, Presidents, Generals, et al, are all part of this group, but also it can be a regional manager, a restaurant owner, or a sergeant in a small unit or a parent that needs to figure how to motivate her or his children to be educated.


I link the last level of leadership primarily links with the situational approach. Any given circumstance is embedded in a geographical area that is in turn affected by changes for near and other farther away regions of our world, the world in which we live and now appears to be a global and small shopping mall.

The Three Models

Participative Leadership

The leader shares it decision-making power with the employees and/or allows them to influence her or him. The leader does not take decisions autocratically; rather, the leader might consult with employees then takes the decisions alone, or perhaps the leader could decide to take the decision jointly with employees or just the leader would delegate the entire decision-making process to others (Yukl, 2002).




Figure 2


It is a very interesting model, by the way, I think it is the most effective, not only because it is inclusive. It involves people and might facilitate, within multiple other factors, teamwork, positive morale and enthusiasm, but because and by the simple fact that one brain rarely think better than many brains, and even if it could, there will be not proper checks or balances system in place to contrast the leader’s decisions or views against other viable alternatives. Since power means the ability to make decisions on what needs to be done, when, how and by whom. In addition, It also implies the determination of what resources are going to be utilized by whom, and how much it is going to be utilized and for how long I present below a illustration of how the participative leadership is compare according its power style among two other styles, the autocratic and the free-rein.




Figure 3



Path-Goal Theory of leadership


This theory is categorized by Yukl (2002) as one of the contingency theories of effective leadership. This theory studies the probable correlation between the leader’s behavior (LB) and the employees’ job satisfaction and under certain favorable conditions LB effects in the employees’ performance. (p. 212-216)


Yukl explains that Path-Goal theory utilizes a motivation theory, called “expectancy theory” where the desirability of an outcome is denominated its “valence” and the perceived probability of an outcome is known as “expectancy”. The expectancy theory shows why employees rationally decide to make a maximal, moderate or minimal effort to accomplish a task based on their initial perception on how successful they would be in attaining it. Thus the leader’s job is to change or influence those negative perceptions who would inhibit or detriment the employees’ performance and outcomes. Yukl indicates that in this theory the LB uses supportive, directive, participative and achievement-oriented leadership. (p. 212-216)

The Path-Goal Theory of leadership can be useful or advantageous in stressful situations where there are complex and tedious tasks to accomplish or scenarios to deal with, as for instance “EL ARADO” and Plow of the Sean Inc., merger. In addition, it appears that positive correlations exist with the leader’s supportive leadership and the employees’ job satisfaction and increase of their self-confidence; moreover, there seem to be negative correlations of the leader’s supportive skills and employees’ anxiety and the unpleasant perceptions about work.


Figure 4




The main disadvantage of the Path-Goal theory is its complexity and its reliance on the expectancy theory of motivation thereby it could create uncertainty an ambiguity, which in fact would have a negative impact on the employees’ motivation. (p. 212-216).


Servant Leadership Approach


I have learned that to have followers and making them to accomplish organizational goals does not qualify you as a leader. The purpose of a leader needs to be to be also ethical, i.e. looking to achieve the highest good for the most people. A leader needs to inspire rather than only motivate its followers to do the right things. Over my past experiences, in which in spite of my reluctance and against my will, I would have had accomplished certain tasks but only because I was forced unfairly to do it so in a coercive way by a mean supervisor. The fact that I did those demanded tasks does not make that person, who forced me to do them, a leader. It just hold the power of my paycheck.


Suddenly as I remembered those instances, an inquiry came into my mind, and somehow I needed to know if there were, and I thought at the time that it was reasonable to believe it so, a model of leadership that deals with purpose and ethics. And I found it: the Servant Leadership (SL) approach. According to Yukl (2002), Robert K. Greenleaf coined the term 1970 and wrote a book about it in 1977 and now it appears the many corporations are using SL as guideline for their business strategic plans.


The main tenet of this model is that employees are human beings who have different needs and for such they ought to have meaningful jobs and thus the leader’s main responsibility is to empower, listen and empathize with them. Greenleaf sustains that looking for the well-being and developing of the employees is as important as providing high quality services for our customers. SL antagonist model is the Authoritative Hierarchical (AH) model which usually uses power and coercive mechanisms to obtain a forced loyalty or action, from the followers; in contrast, the SL uses open communication and honesty to earn the respect and trust among the followers.


I hardly see any disadvantage in applying the SL model; however, those who confirm themselves Machiavellians, point that the SL is permissive and give too much power to people, same power that the followers can use against the leader; which the ill-intentioned Machiavellians find a very undesirable outcome for leaders, princesses, dictators, ‘SteveBallmers’, ‘BillGateses’, ‘SteveJobses’, as other tyrants, et al. I like to think of this model as a follower-centered approach; and as an effective leadership model to achieve goals without causing harm or imposing ideas onto others too, let alone remembering the environment.


I like a lot this method for “EL ARADO” and Plow of the Sea Inc. merger; it fits my personal traits and ideas about responsible management. As stated by Wong & Page (2003) “Most of the companies at the top of Fortune Magazine’s best companies to work for in America have adopted some aspects of SL. There are at least two reasons for its resurgence: (1) SL is part of the larger movement away from command-and-control leadership towards participatory and process-oriented leadership in the Information Technology [IT]-based economy, and (2) SL holds the promise of an ethical and socially responsible management and leadership as an antidote to corporate scandals.” (p. 1)










Figure 5


“If you are planning for one year, grow rice. If you are planning for twenty years, grow trees. If you are planning for centuries, grow men.” – A Chinese Proverb

The Golden Model: Participative Leadership Approach


There are not simple choices for leaders; more importantly, as a Director facing an acquisition, I know that merges usually cause the following: Intention of turnover, nervousness or stress, job dissatisfaction or insecurity among staff, in one famous acronym: FUD [Fear, Uncertainty and doubt]. Using this approach the leader and the employees will be able to interact and thus they will be able to communicate more clearly to each other, they will hear their own voices in decision-making process and most likely, they will adapt more easily to the merge.

However, when using this model often, it is difficult getting a decent consensus among staff members and other factors are added-on, such as time consumed by numerous long meetings, the decision-making will take more time. Eventually, it will require and drain more time, motivation and cooperation from the employees’ part as for the leader’s part to continue the making-decision process. Anyway, what in the world that is genuine, and for such worth it, Would not call your best efforts to obtain it?


The participative leadership model is the democratic and inclusive way to make decisions and to achieve objectives and goals. I think is the best one for a merger in which two cultures will and need to fuse into a new one, a sort of social phenomena, known as transculturation.

One caveat, though, in the situational approach we found two major subcategories of research, one it is group under the label contingency theories of leadership. These theories study the correlation between the leader attributes and situational variables. Therefore; effective leaders use, or know how and when to use, different leadership styles according to the situation, their experience, the moment, and more importantly, according to their traits, values and principles. Something that some people would ever would like to or could consider to change, their attitude towards others and even towards themselves. Incidentally, we can point in here to the difference between Gandhi and Hitler; or Bob Taylor's and Larry Roberts' expert leadership style, compare with the greedy and jerky moves of Ballmer and Gates, as the profound difference between Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak . For instance, Jobs is selling iPods, and applications for his iPhone or whatever it is. In the meantime, “WOZ” is living a quite life. He is playing his guitar. Wrote his book. He is teaching children at the school. He went to finish his college education. I just cannot imagine Steve Jobs doing this, he would never will be able to do any of that. He is far too egoistical and egomaniac. Nevertheless, I have watched and listened many of his former employees to state that they were very glad because they were not working anymore under the ‘Jobs’ of his [referring to Steve Jobs in here] ““leadership””. [All of this has been very well documented, written and filmed not once but many times]

My question, it is why we are still listening to these people? Perhaps, we think that these people are the leaders or our times, and so they do epitomize our culture. It is a catastrophic confusion, I think, they are not leaders, they are opportunists, they are "crocodiles", and not even sharks. Sharks do not cry while they are eating at their victims, yes they did not have partners they only have victims. Ok, you do not believe me, I give you one proof of it, listen to what Metcalfe has to say [the inventor of Ethernet] on his deal with Microsoft, more specifically about his then Network Operating System [clue: Around the time of Windows 3.11 for workgroups].

It is nothing wrong, until these “predators” got so lucky and powerful that their erroneous way of life is having devastating consequences in the economy, in the industries, at our jobs, in the academics, in our children education, at the non-profit sectors, in the news, and finally in the government. For many people these are icons. However for some of us, who know what they really are and how ugly they sucks, and as I stated sometime ago, they constitute a new kind of “Gura”, they are the new idols with the feet of silicone, and so they seem to be the Geekiest Muppets of our time but not more than that for sure. History will tell us this... however there are more than couple books, articles and films.


I forgot to mention the leadership of "The Monkey Boy"




Bibliography


Big Dog Leadership Styles, [Web Site]. U.S. Army. Available: https://atiam.train.army.mil/soldierPortal/atia/adlsc/view/public/4788-1/fm/22-100/ch1.htm [2006, January 03, 2006].

Clark, D. (2001, October). Leadership (May 15, 2001), [Shareware Material]. Donald Clark. Available: http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/documents/leadershipshareware.html [2006, January 04].


Wong, P. T. P., & Page, D. (2003). Servant leadership: An Opponent-Process Model and the Revised Servant Leadership Profile, Servant Leadership Roundtable (pp. 1- 13).

Yukl, G. (2002). Leadership In Organizations (5th Edition ed.). Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall Inc.

U.S. Army Handbook (1973). Military Leadership.

Monday, June 02, 2008

Plausible Effective Change Models for Yahoo & Microsoft Merge

Effective Change Models for Managing Merging Organizations with seemed Conflicting Cultures

By John Manuel K.

This study surveys different change models & how to understand and managing change facing two conflicting cultures in the verge to be merged. For effecting the abstraction, I have named these two corporations with seemingly opposite & conflicting cultures as: "AAA" & "OOO"

Change alone is Unchanging

Heraclites AKA Heraclitus (c. 535- c.475 BC.)

As a result of the identification of many potential conflicting cultural factors between the AAA and the OOO Corporations, and enacting the role as the AAA Director of the Fulfillment Applications of the information department, I became aware of the need to study effective change models not only to manage the merging process between the AAA and the OOO corps., but also to create and strategic plan that it will use to optimize the whole merging process. As a major milestone for creating such a strategic plan, this study starts by exploring three organizational change models, by identifying situations in which their application will be most effective, and finally, by analyzing advantages and/or disadvantages in following these models.

Opposition brings concord.

Out of discord comes the fairest harmony.

Heraclites AKA Heraclitus (c. 535- c.475 BC.)

The Meaning of Change

I understand change as a “flux”, or a process and not as a final product or as a specific result that is manifested before our consciousness as a result of our instantiation of this process under our observation, with the purpose to study a determined object(s), as in here the purpose of study is about organizational Change models. It is a cyclical, episodic or periodic study indeed.

In the first chapter, “the purpose”, of his book [by the way the young Hillary Clinton (our next President), would have had written her thesis about this author]: “Rules for Radicals,” Saul D. Alinsky (1971) wrote: “Change means movement. Movement means friction. Only in the frictionless vacuum of a nonexistent abstract world can movement or change occur without that abrasive friction of conflict.” I assume this quote personifies well what is about to happen between two cultures which seem to have some many ways of doing things differently, as the AAA and OOO corporations: but we are conducting this research to be better equipped to managing an effective change.

It feels lacerating, but as the record shows, if we do not consider the human factors and culture the merging process will be erratically implemented with serious repercussion not only in the morale of the staff but also in our performance and lost of market value, instead to have positive outcome. It would probably defeat the merger’s purpose.

In this regard, I prize the inputs of Jerry (Gerald) Weinberg who has written many books combining seemed equidistant subjects as technical software development and human factors in improving productivity, this is a sort of software anthropology.

In an interview Weinberg explained how he realized the importance of people transformation in the Software Development of Technical organizations, and how this perception lead him to study the work of Virginia Satir, who, Weinberg, indicated that she is often referred as “The Columbus of Family therapy” and how her Satir’s work forms the basis of Neurolinguistic Programming (NLP), basically Weinberg state during this interview what it was his main “discovery”: “…The Software team works together to produce software; the family works to make new people …” (Dorset House Publishing, 2006). Thus, as implausible as it may sound, Weinberg also ‘confessed’ in this interview that he learned more about effective programming from Satir that from any other person in his life (Dorset House Publishing, 2006). Weinberg’s research supports our newly gained understanding that human factors are of primary importance for technical organizations, especially when they are facing an eminent cultural clash as again it seems to be the case with AAA and OOO.

Change Models

Organizations are made by people, thus Virginia Satir estates, “Change happens one person at a time” (Smith, 2006). Weinberg further states that the Satir Change model implies, “… one day at a time, one choice at a time …” (AYE conference, 2006). The whole point is that the organizational change occurs in the individuals, theretofore, in every choice, in every day, in every transaction and the integration of all his “micro-changes”, I will dare to state, quantum changes, will effect and affect a systemic change in the organizations.

Some outcomes will and can be anticipated properly but others that should/could be anticipated, perhaps might be ignored, or not addressed accordingly and thus chaos could and will be the unexpected guest of an otherwise avoided situation. Returning once more to Weinberg writes: “Change is a long-term process, but a living organization lives in the immediate present. Thus, without careful management, long-term change is invariably sacrificed to short-term expedience” (Research Triangular Park, 2006). In this regard, I would rather be effective than efficient.

Thus we can see that organizational changes start at the level of each individual, each transaction, each choice, at everyday, as matter of fact multiple of these changes happens simultaneously, some are perceptible and some are not. As a company in its way to be merged with a company like OOO with antagonistic culture we at AAA must understand some main organizational change models to assist us to put our upcoming merger at easy. There are three main types of organization change models: top-down; transformational leadership; and strategic approaches (Kinsman & Laporte, 2006).

The Satir Merger Model

Figure 1 Satir Change Model

As we can see, the Satir Change Model above (Figure 1), is centered on the tenet that improvement is always possible. Virginia Satir developed this model to assist people to improve their lives by transforming the way they see and express themselves. In this way this change model is transformational in nature. It is a five-phase change model (see Figure 1) displaying the effects each phase has on emotions, cognitive, behaviors and physiology. According to Satir using the principles of this model facilitate how organizations or group process change and how to assist other organization or groups in processing change as well.

This model could be applied in any situation: Before, during and after the completion of the merger. For instance, the phase 1, called the “Late Status Quo” represents AAA culture as is right now, a people-oriented, family like environment whereby there is a sense of belonging, staff knows what to expect, how to react, and how to behave. There are policies and these policies are known and well accepted within the organization (Satir, 1991).

In the second phase, known as “resistance” in this model, the OOO culture is depicted as the “foreign element”, this is the conflict for AAA staff and a probable source of uncertainty, doubt, and discomfort. The Satir Change model allows the understanding of how the situation would appear for the staff since their stability is going to be compromised by the OOO and its conflicting culture. Restless behavior and some another resistance tactics can be developed among the staff as a mechanism of defense. Is in this phase that this model prescribes to assist employees to become aware of their reaction of denial, avoidance or blaming by opening up to others staff members.

I the third phase, in this model: the chaos, the merge eventually has happened and this phase discovers the unknown, because for more plans that management could make always there are many details that remain unknown to us, and for such “obscure.” There will be employees that could feel nervous after the loss of some of their counterparts because the merger and they probably will develop symptoms of anxiety and other characteristic of the sorts. This phase should be expected by managers as erratic periods and also as an opportunity for assisting staff to search for beneficial relationships with the “foreign element” the new staff and culture from OOO. This is the stage where under Satir Change model transformation happens (Weinberg, 1997).

In Phase four, i.e. the integration, the staff of AAA will encounter at least some positive attributes in OOO and in consequence new projects and relationships will be implemented rapidly and with positive energy, and thus we arrive at Phase five: New Status Quo, whereby change have been assimilated, the Merger have been completed and a new environment has emerged and a new sense of accomplishment and enhancing possibilities are permeating this new organization that has been derived from the Merger of AAA and OOO (Satir, 1991).

The advantage of this model is that provides to us proven ways to deal with the entire process of the merger, The Satir Change Model simplifies the scenario of how people react when face change, as in this case a merger, and what management needs to do about in each phase or stage of the process. I hardly see any disadvantage, only that requires a lot planning and support from management since is very granular and its focused in many dimensions, including the physiological reactions of the individuals. I would gladly use this model because it seems to be centered on transforming cultures by assistant each staff member to adapt to the pressing demands of doing so.

Nadler-Tushman Change Model: Key Variables

This model observes how change is managed or face, according to the extent in which change(s) can be anticipated, thus there are two types of changes: Anticipatory changes are planned changes based on expected situations. Example: Insurance needed for Paintings in the Exhibition and reactive changes: Changes made in response to unexpected situations. What decisions you make when you were alone at home and suddenly you fractured your femur and fibula by accident? (Kritner, 2004).

The Nadler and Tushamn model provides the following steps:

1) Identify the problems and Situational analysis - Get support of key power groups

2) Demonstrate leadership support of the change

3) Use symbols / Create identification w/ the change and appearance of a critical mass of support

4) Build in stability

5) Surface/create dissatisfaction w/ the current state

6) Obtain the appropriate levels of participation in planning/implementing change

7) Reward desired behavior in transition to future state

8) Provide time and opportunity to disengage from current state

9) Develop and communicate a clear image of the future state

10) Use multiple and consistent leverage points

11) Use transition devices

12) Obtain feedback about the transition state and evaluate success

This case Model primary advantage is that considers also what we could do when facing unexpected changes, as we know for this merger we need a flexible yet a structure model that guide us in the process, this modes does just that by providing opportunities for disengagement and also using multiple leverage points. One of the best situation to use this model is during the implementation phase when new rules or policies are going to be applied to newly created groups and projects has been formed within perhaps same or new departments. The disadvantage is the amount of time that will take to analyze, and for planning the strategic plan to facilitate this merger.

Models of Action Research: Cummings & Worley Model et al

The majority of research is aimed to create knowledge; action research is a way to conduct studies which engages in both: taking action and creating knowledge constituting a theory of action (Coghlan & Brannick, 2001, p.xi). Organizations use action research models to learn how to change significant aspect of its system by involving their members to actively study their own behaviors, from here action research shows the new knowledge emanated from the self-reflection of the participants on the whole research process.

Many actions action research models exist, all of them includes in their definition as iterative, collaborative, and change effort that involve needs analysis, plan of action based on the needs analysis, implementation of the plan of action and finally evaluation of the process. I identified four of this models Cummings and Worley Model, Burke’s Adaptation of W. L. French classic 11–step Model, Frohman, Sashkin and Kavanagh’s Seven-Phase Model and Pearce and Robinsons Six-Step Model. The entire aforementioned models are very similar but the most notable or the one that is more referred, in my literature review, is the Cummings and Worley Model (Cummings & Worley, 1991, p. 155) here is the well delineated stages:

1) Motivating Change creating readiness for change and overcoming resistance to change

2) Creating a Vision - Describing the Core Ideology and Constructing the Envisioned Future

3) Development political support -- Assessing Change Agent Power and Identifying Key stakeholders and Influencing stakeholders.

4) Managing the Transition - Activity Planning and commitment planning and management structure.

5) Sustaining Momentum - Providing Resources for Change and Building a Support System for Change Agents and Developing New Competencies and Skills and Reinforcing New Behaviors

The Cummings and Worley model takes in account the anxiety and other emotional factors introducing in its first “prescription”: Motivating change by creating readiness for change, very interesting concept, it includes leadership because it compel to create a vision a core ideology, in this sense is also a transformational change mode. And takes in account the power by identifying key people, I think that this model also is applicable for the merger, especially in the planning and commitment for facilitate the merger by creating appropriate structures of management to sustain development into a new culture.

There are many advantages, in using this model principally; it is straight forward, as it appears to be easy to follow, and on the other hand, few disadvantages can be noticed about this model, perhaps is too compact and lack of specificity to anticipate unknowns.

In closing we have idenfied tree change models: The Satir Change, Nadler & Tushman, and the Cummings & Worley Change model. We have explored situations in which they can be utilized and finally, we analyze each model, according to their advantage or disadvantages in following these models.

References

Alinsky, S. D. (1971). Rules for Radicals. New York: Random House.

Anderson, P. & Tushman, M. L. (eds.) (2004). Managing Strategic Innovation and Change - a Collection of Readings - Second Edition. New York: Oxford University

AYE (Amplifying Your Effectiveness) Conference. NoMoreResolutions. Retrieved January 25, 2006, from http://www.ayeconference.com/wiki/scribble.cgi?read=NoMoreResolutions.

Burke, W. W. (1982). Organization development: Principles and practices. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman.

Coghlan, D., & Brannick, T. (2000). Doing action research in your own organization. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

Cummings, T. G. & Worley C. G. (2001). Organization Development and Change - Seventh Edition.Mason, OH: South-Western College Publishing - Thomson Learning.


Plowed Results | Resultados Arados